Amazon sells two small Alexa speakers for under fifty bucks and the naming helps nobody. The Echo Pop and the Echo Dot look nearly identical in photos, sit about ten dollars apart, and answer to the same wake word. So we lined up the spec sheets and read through a pile of owner reviews to figure out where that ten dollar gap lives. Short version: its in the sound, plus a handful of sensors Amazon quietly left out of the Pop.

Where the ten dollars goes

Here is the funny part. On paper the Pop has the bigger driver, 1.95 inches against 1.73. Owner reviews tell a different story, and it’s one of the most consistent patterns we found: the Dot sounds fuller. The sphere gives the audio somewhere to breathe, so you get low end that a wedge this size has no business producing. The Pop plays plenty loud on a desk or a nightstand, but push the volume in a living room and things turn flat and a little harsh.

Then there are the sensors. The Dot has a temperature sensor, which sounds like a gimmick until you wire it into a routine. Room hits 78 degrees, Alexa flips on a smart plug with a fan attached. We covered cheap plug options in our smart plugs under $20 roundup if you want to build that. The Dot also responds to taps on top, snooze an alarm or pause a song, and it can sense motion with ultrasound so a routine fires when you walk in. The Pop does none of this. Not a dealbreaker for a speaker that mostly sets timers, but it explains the price gap better than the audio does.

The case for the Pop anyway

Price. Thats the case. The Pop lists at $39.99 but spends half the year discounted, and during big sale events it has dropped close to twenty dollars. At that number it stops competing with the Dot and starts competing with not owning a speaker at all. Good pick for a kids room, a garage, or a third Alexa endpoint in a house where better speakers already handle the music.

The front firing design has one honest advantage too. Sitting at a desk with the speaker aimed at your face, voice replies come through clearly at low volume. Some people prefer that over the Dot trying to fill the whole room.

What they share

Same Alexa, same app, same timers and routines and skills. Both work as eero wifi extenders, which is a quiet perk if your network already runs on eero. Neither one has an aux jack, and neither has a Zigbee hub built in, that still requires a full size Echo. If you are weighing Amazon against Google before committing, our Echo Dot vs Nest Mini comparison covers that fight, and we rounded up Echo Dot alternatives if neither of these feels right. For day to day impressions of the Dot itself, our Echo Dot review goes deeper.

Echo Dot (5th Gen), Pros & Cons

Echo Pop, Pros & Cons

Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.